|
Time after time I found really inexcusable errors and even text that was at odds with captions under illustrations on the same page. Quite frankly I found almost nothing in this book that would have warranted purchasing it. To be fair, there were some interesting photographs and an occational bit of new information. I've read some poorly written books in my day; but this book was at the top of the list. I rated this book one star because the program required a rating.
But for the most part it was a rehash of common knowledge that anyone could have accessed. I'd rather have rated it no stars. I was appalled by the sheer amount of misinformation that anyone with even a modicum of knowledge of Gilded Age architecture would recognize. I'm sorry I did. What I find so annoying is that this book was written by someone who should have known better and was published by a reputable company.
"High society in the 19th century was different from you and me and these ornate luxury, money pits of houses proves that while you can't take it with you, you can sure spend it when you are here."
The best book for those interested in the history of these great homes and the people that lived in them. Highly recommended
This is important for the expert who thought he/she had seen it all.b) the book is beautifully produced. This adds to the credibility. So many of these books end up confusing names and the generations they belong to. Ive read dozens on this subject (old and new) and Craven's book does the following very well.a) includes heretofore unpublished photos of homes and people. I agree with the reviewer in N.C.
If you are an expert in this subject then you want your Vanderbilts, Burdens, Webbs and Astors correctly named and dated. This is an excellent book. Lush, high grade paper, invitingly formatted. d) the bibliography contains books that I did not even know of.All and all and excellent result. c) gets all the names and generations right.
One of the best books on the Gilded Age Ive seen. Lots of color pics too.
|